https://prod-files-secure.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/cc7e7aa4-dc92-4b8c-85de-960d9147e178/c3a588bf-cf32-4c69-861e-ee6ae8e2b21d/Agnes_Grey_and_Animals.pdf
Anne Brontë’s novel “Agnes Grey” touches on themes of animal cruelty and the relationship between humans and animals. The protagonist, Agnes Grey, observes and often contrasts the treatment of animals by different characters, which reflects their moral standing and social behaviors.
In the novel, Agnes Grey, working as a governess, uses ecological metaphors to describe her experiences and interactions. She compares her role in educating children to nurturing plants and observes the life cycles of flora and fauna, assigning them to characters in the novel. This approach draws on early nineteenth-century science and prefigures contemporary concerns in animal studies and ecocriticism1.
The novel also highlights the contrast between characters who exhibit kindness towards animals, like Mr. Weston, and those who are cruel, such as Mr. Hatfield and the Bloomfield family. The treatment of animals serves as a reflection of the characters’ empathy and morality. For instance, Mr. Weston’s gentle approach to a dog is set against Mr. Hatfield’s abuse of the same animal1.
Moreover, the novel suggests a parallel between the exploitation of animals and the objectification and exploitation of women and the lower classes during the Victorian era. Critics have noted that morally upright characters like Agnes, who empathize with the pain of other creatures, are often undermined by those who exhibit predatory behavior and exert physical or fiscal authority over both human and nonhuman organisms1.
In essence, “Agnes Grey” uses the treatment of animals as a lens to critique social hierarchies and to advocate for empathy and kindness towards all living beings. The novel’s exploration of these themes remains relevant today, as it encourages readers to consider the ethical implications of their interactions with both humans and animals.